Remixed Up In The Music Leagues

I had rarely used Spotify as a way of listening to music, never mind thought about paying a subscription to stream songs, before this year. Now I am addicted.* Here’s why.

In February, my friend Aled Roberts, the Damwain out of Hap a Damwain, invited me to join his Spotify Music League.

I had no idea what he was talking about and was reluctant at first as I wasn’t a fan of the piss poor levels of return musicians got from the streaming site and didn’t want to ‘join the dark side’ by giving them any money. Once it was pointed out that I could play the Music League with a free account and that The Music League was pretty much a separate entity, I was in.

The idea is that a number of rounds are set up with specific criteria and the players select a suitable song. The first round I played was this one:

Perhaps surpisingly, and definitely wrongly, I didn’t submit a Datblygu track – I thought it was a bit obvious – rather I sumbitted the wonderful ‘The New Adam and Eve’ from Cardiff’s very own Simon Love.

Once all players has submitted their songs, a Spotify playlist was produced and we had 3 days to listen and decide how to use our votes. We each had 40 up votes to use (with a maximum of 8 on any one song), but also 7 down votes we had to use. Sadly, Simon’s song didn’t do as well as it should have, mostly because the majority of other players didn’t know he was Welsh, but I finished a creditable (I thought) 28th out of 45 – it was a huge league!

The game continues over a number of different rounds and as I write we are about to start the penultimate ,11th, round – more on this later. I have even managed to win a round – where we had to submit songs that weren’t in English – quite rightly, my selection of Sakuran Zensen hitting top spot.

Having really enjoyed the experience of being in a League, it was perhaps inevitable that I set up my own. I invited mostly people I know, but also a few online friends and some of the people from the Damwain league, who at least knew what they were doing.

This League has just finished after 10 rounds that included Songs Without Guitars, Songs by Someone And The Somethings, Songs Under 90 Seconds, Sad Songs About Specific Places, etc., etc., and so on. It has been a brilliant way to not only share some of the less well known songs that I think others will enjoy, but also to discover new music myself. As a result of submissions from both these Leagues, I have gone out and bought music in physical form. For example, the CD with this track on it from Ffug.

The inaugural Kicker’s Invitational has been such a success that a follow-up has already been set up and 22 players are ready to get going next week with a round for songs with an imperative in the title. Go figure! Anyway, it would be remiss of me not to share the top placings in the first League, you may recognise the name at the top.

No more to be said about that.

Funnily enough, the reason for me wanting to write about these Leagues, apart from hopefully finding more players for future competitions, is actually down to the current round in the Damwain League.

I have generally found myself making long shortlists of contenders for each round before making my decision except for this current round. The criteria this time is Remixes, and I couldn’t think of anything. I realised that I am not really a fan of the remix, and tend to see it as just a case of stretching out the original unnecessarily. Nevertheless, having been on a bit of a Microdisney deep dive recently, my first thought was this version of the Fatima Mansions song The Loyaliser.

Pretty good, right? But, frankly, not a patch on the original. Looking through my CDs I remembered that I actually have an album called Remixed, by the band Grand Gestures, so that’s where I went next. I really like the original Grand Gestures albums, and the track A Certain Compulsion they do with Emma Pollock on vocals is a particular favourite. This is the remix:

Again, I really like this, but not as much as the 7 minute original.

So, where to turn next? Who do I know who obsesses over the minutiae of different versions of songs, who is somewhat of an expert of the more obscure corners of electronica, who has, in fact remixed (well, redited) my own band Tom Violence, the man behind The Grand Gestures, Dundee’s very own Jan Burnett of off out of the band Spare Snare.

So, I contacted Jan and asked him to tell me his top three favourite remixes. After a full 25 minutes, he came back with this list and a few words about each.

Happy Mondays – Wrote For Luck (Vince Clarke Remix)

Factory trying to give Happy Mondays some credibility and club presence. At the time Vince didn’t really do other peoples remixes, and HM had no hits, they still didnt until Perfecto came along in their original guise of Oakenfold and Osborne, with Terry Farley.

Depeche Mode – Enjoy The Silence (The Quad: Final Mix)

Three original 12″s exist, and three original CD singles… Mute obviously knew this was a big hitter. The Quad final mix pulls together bits of all the other mixes and puts it on a one sided 15 minute 33rpm monster. It’s lovely.

Frankie Goes To Hollywood – The Power Of Love (Blank & Jones so80s Reconstruction)

Technically not a remix, ie they’ve not added any new sounds or beats, but just used all the original stems to make this epic version. I could listen to it on repeat forever.

Thanks Jan! I was surely onto a winner here now.

But then I felt a pang of something I don’t usually get pangs about. Was this cheating? Could I really submit a Remix I hadn’t actually heard before?

Well, dear reader, with the Remix Round not yet voted for, I had better not say just yet. After the votes are in I will come back to this post and reveal all.

For now, though, you can find the Music Leagues I am currently involved in on the following links. You should be able to access the playlists there, but if not, and you would like to, just let me know below, and I’ll send you a link. By the way, the Stockport League still has places if you’d like to join before 14 May, so don’t delay!

Stockport Invitational

Kicker’s Invitational

Another Kicker’s Invitational

An Accidental League (Cynghrair Damwaineol)

They Might Be A Music League – a They Might Be Giants League set up by Kicker Jr.

*I still don’t pay a subscription to Spotify and buy music on Bandcamp to support the artists I like, but still.

Robert Pollard’s Guide To The 60s – Tape 38: Trout Mask Replica – Captain Beefheart And His Magic Band

Hoy! Hoy! Two wizards chatting about that third Beefheart album is neither fast nor bulbous, but you still might want to give us a listen, got me?

You can find out what we thought by clicking on the image below.

Endorsement from Uncle Bob for the Captain (photo unearthed by: Esteban Entwistle)

You can find the podcast with Bill Harlkeroad (Zoot Horn Rollo) that Chorizo mentions here:

https://www.samuelandreyev.com/seehear

Our chats about the previous tapes can be found where you found this one.

To avoid any potential disappointment on missing out on the next show, make sure you follow our podcast on Spotify or subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

Robert Pollard’s Guide To The 60s – Tape 37: Safe As Milk / Strictly Personal – Captain Beefheart And His Magic Band

Sure ’nuff ‘n yes it is Captain Beefheart and His Magic Band who make it onto Robert Pollard’s tape number 37.

You can find out what we thought of the first two Beefheart albums by clicking on the image below.

As discussed in the show, here are pictures of the back of Kicker’s copy of Strictly Personal. If you are the author, please do get in touch!

Our chats about the previous tapes can be found where you found this one.

To avoid any potential disappointment on missing out on the next show, make sure you follow our podcast on Spotify or subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

Robert Pollard’s Guide To The 60s – Tape 36: The Psychedelic Sounds Of / Easter Everywhere – The 13th Floor Elevators

Going up! In this show we take on the first two albums from those psychedelic pioneers, the 13th Floor Elevators, electric jug and all.

You can find out what we thought by clicking on the image below.

Our chats about the previous tapes can be found where you found this one.

To avoid any potential disappointment on missin’ out on the next show, make sure you follow our podcast on Spotify or subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

Chorizo Garbanzo’s Favourite Things Of 2023

In early December, I got together with Kicker to record our podcast number 125. If you listen to that you’ll hear me playing and discussing my 24 favourite songs of the year.

Here are some more things that I really enjoyed putting into my ears and eyes in 2023.

Favourite albums

My top 7 albums (in no particular order)…

25 more of my favourite albums …

A record of nearly all the albums I’ve listened to this year can be found here.

Favourite EPs

Favourite instrumental albums

Favourite cover versions

Favourite re-issue

See That Girl – Kirsty MacColl

There have been loads of Kirsty compilations before but finally here’s a definitive 8CD round-up of her brilliant and diverse catalogue. The albums we already know and love are here (Kite, Electric Landlady, Titanic Days, Tropical Brainstorm)

There’s also an unreleased album (Real from 1983) and unsurprisingly it’s really good. Plus a load of BBC Session and live songs and a chance to hear again Kirsty’s stunning demo version of Dear John, a break-up song so heartbreakingly sad she couldn’t bring herself to release it. (She gave the song to Eddi Reader instead)

Favourite music videos

  • Nerve – Do Nothing
  • Eggman – Ty Segall
  • The Feeling – Personal Trainer (This song should’ve been in my favourite songs of the year podcast, but I’d already finalised my list by the time it came out at the start of December)

Best gigs of the year

It’s been a very busy year! I’ve been to 74 gigs and seen more than 150 different bands. I’ll summarise my 2023 gig-going exploits in a separate blog post.

Sadly missed…

Sinead & Shane

Both key components in my music collection since my teenage years. Both have made records that can emotionally move me like very few others. Both of them have played gigs that are up there as the very best I’ve ever seen. No-one else can get a crowd bouncing like The Pogues could and nobody can sing like Sinead. I’ve also been lucky enough to talk with both of them in person, albeit fairly briefly in both cases. Sadly neither of their deaths came as a surprise. Their various health battles have been fairly public and like everyone else I’ve been kind of expecting to hear news that they’re gone for a few years now. But that doesn’t make it any less tragic or upsetting. Long live the music and the memories they’ve left us with.

By contrast, the first time I heard of Richard Laviolette was when I read of his passing in September. I’ve since become a big fan of his music and 2 albums in particular, Taking The Long Way Home and All Of Your Raw Materials. These and many more are available to buy on his Bandcamp page. He was a very talented songwriter with amazing lyrics and it’s sadly ironic that I’ve only become aware of him posthumously because he’s got the best song about funerals that’s ever been written!

Favourite fiction books

Not necessarily released in 2023, but that’s when I got round to reading them!

If you like well-written horror stories with a sense of humour then I can’t recommend Grady Hendrix highly enough. I first found out about him when I read his book The Final Girl Support Group in 2022. This year I’ve read 4 more by him and I think they’re even better.

  • My Best Friend’s Exorcism
  • How To Sell A Haunted House
  • The Southern Book Club’s Guide To Slaying Vampires
  • Horrorstör

Favourite fiction audiobook

Cutey & The Sofaguard by Chris Wade

I don’t even know where to begin describing this but you can buy it here for a bargain 3 quid. It’s narrated by exactly who you’d want to hear narrating such a strange story full of barking mad characters, the late, great Rik fucking Mayall, dialling his Rik Mayallness up to 11 and beyond.

If you’re a Rik Mayall fan you will absolutely love this. If you’re not, then fuck off because you’re wrong.

Favourite music books

I Wanna Be Yours by John Cooper Clarke

I borrowed the audiobook of this from my local library, read by The Bard Of Salford himself. Your local library gives you free access to the Borrowbox app so get listening to this book as soon as you can because it’s a wonderfully great listen! The man has a way with words as we all know and his frequent tangents about films, breakfast cereal, fashion or whatever are equal parts fascinating and hilarious. As the tagline from the After Eight adverts quoted in the book several times puts it, listening to this was “Luxury, pure unashamed luxury”

The Philosophy Of Modern Song by Bob Dylan

This one is also freely available on on that same app. There’s an impressive cast of narrators here, Bob himself of course but also Helen Mirren, Sissy Spacek, Oscar Isaac and the whole of The Dude’s bowling team, Jeff Bridges, Steve Buscemi and John Goodman.

If it was up to me, I’d have these 3 narrating every audiobook.

Other recommended music books I read this year:

  • Paper Cuts: How I Destroyed The British Music Press & Other Misadventures by Ted Kessler
  • Why Karen Carpenter Matters by Karen Tongson
  • Born in the USA: Bruce Springsteen and the American Tradition by Jim Cullen

Favourite non-fiction books

  • Lucky Jack (1894-2000) by Sue Bavey
  • Over the Edge of the World: Magellan’s Terrifying Circumnavigation of the Globe by Laurence Bergreen
  • From Winning Teams To Broken Dreams by Dominic Ball

Favourite films 

Top 10 films I’ve seen this year:

  • Lapsis
  • The Trip
  • Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri
  • A Dark Song
  • Smile
  • The Harder They Fall
  • Men
  • Evil Dead Rise
  • Ventoux
  • Triangle Of Sadness

15 others I really liked too:

  • The Oak Room
  • Seven Stages To Achieve Eternal Bliss
  • Guardians Of The Galaxy Vol. 3
  • The Banshees Of Inisherin
  • The Unbearable Weight Of Massive Talent
  • Amsterdam
  • Willy’s Wonderland
  • Nocebo
  • No One Will Save You
  • Nobody
  • The Hater
  • Brightburn
  • Violent Night
  • Come To Daddy
  • The Menu

Favourite TV shows

All my favourite TV shows this year have the word “dead” in the title. Don’t know what that says about me?

Deadloch

Scandi noir if it was set in Tasmania. And had shitloads of swearing. Incredible writing and acting, best TV series I’ve watched in many years.


Ash Vs Evil Dead

I watched the first series of this when it came out nearly 10 years ago! I didn’t even realise they’d made a 2nd and 3rd series until it popped up on Netflix. Safe to say this won’t be to everyone’s tastes but if you like your horror dark, daft and gory then get into this. Great to see Lee Majors, the bionic man himself, turn up as Ash’s dad.


Dead End

This Polish-made series is the old story of a heist gone wrong but with great characters and several twists and turns along the way.

Favourite documentary

  • Ian Cognito: A Life & Death On Stage – brilliant and touching film about the stand-up comedian who died onstage in 2019. I caught him several times when I used to frequent the comedy clubs of Ealing / Acton / Hammersmith / Chiswick back in the 1990s. He was always uncompromising and a bit of a loose cannon onstage and sometimes off it too it seems. As with Sean Lock, the phrase “the comedian’s comedian” comes up quite a bit and love for both the performer and the man comes across very well from many of his fellow comedians that appear in the film.

Other documentaries I really liked:

  • Whirlybird – film about pioneer of helicopter news reporting Zoey Tur, soundtrack by Ty Segall
  • Ronnie O’Sullivan: The Edge Of Everything – behind the scenes with snooker’s GOAT
  • Fire Of Love – the story of vulcanologists husband and wife team Katia and Maurice Krafft. Great story, also includes loads of the most incredible volcano footage you will ever see

Favourite podcasts

Year Of The Iggy

Brilliant biography series on Iggy Pop made by BDWPS, so well-made and informative. I also loved their previous biographies of Joni Mitchell and Stevie Wonder.

Other favourite podcasts:

  • Case 63 (brilliant sci-fi starring Julianne Moore and Oscar Isaac)
  • Who Shat On The Floor At My Wedding? (true crime investigation, very funny. Title tells you all you need to know)
  • The Debutante (Jon Ronson’s latest documentary)
  • The Narrow Caves (weird horror story, written by the always interesting S. Craig Zahler)
  • Bjork: Sonic Symbolism (philosopher Oddný Eir and musicologist Ásmundur Jónsson interview Bjork about each of her albums. I loved it but obviously only of interest to fans of her music!)

Favourite football match

Not applicable 😔

Please help support all the wonderful musicians, filmmakers, writers and creative minds mentioned in the lists above by searching out their records, CDs, downloads, books etc and BUYING THEM!!!

Previous end of year podcasts:

Related articles:

Kicker of Elves’ Favourite Things from 2023

Another year, another blog post starting with my favourite SONG OF THE YEAR – a full run down of all my favourite songs can be heard on one of our end of the year podcasts – the Kicker one – but this one is something of a first with a Welsh language song topping the Kicker charts.

You can follow along in either Welsh or English using the subtitles on the video – diolch i Aled a Stephen am eich help gyda nhw.

Top 25 Albums

1 Spare Snare – The Brutal

A second album recorded with Steve Albini and, dare I say it, the band’s best since Charm. High quality songwriting and musicianship throughout with added brass from Terry Edwards and Gary Barnacle make buying up all the different colour vinyl and different formats a no-brainer. Disappointingly, I missed seeing the band live this year due to illness, but even that was put right with the inclusion of a live set of tracks on the back of the cassette. What a band!

You can hear me and Jan talking more about the album here.

2 Hap A Damwain – Ni Neu Nhw

I saw Aled and Simon perform a short set last year as part of a celebration weekend for fans of Datblygu and was immediately impressed. I bought up their back catalogue and set about trying to improve my Welsh enough to fully appreciate the songwriting. I’m still working on that, but this album is as good a reason as any for keeping going. With a sound that mixes tipyn bach of Super Furries with ychydig o Datblygu, they are definitely a band worth learning a new language for.

3 Zimmerman – Wish You Were Here

A 46 minute song (actually two 23 minute songs on vinyl) about losing his brother. Remarkably, this requiem from Simon Casier manages to draw you in again and again with its mixture of jazz, electronica and even prog rock, where the repetition never feels repetitive and the melancholy is never miserable. A stunning record.

4 The Bug Club – Rare Birds: Hour Of Song

5 Circus Devils – Squeeze The Needle

6 James Yorkston & The Second Hand Orchestra – The Great White Sea Eagle

7 Sparklehorse – Bird Machine

8 Graeme Jefferies – Canary In A Coalmine

9 Guided By Voices – La La Land

10 The Declining Winter – Really Early, Really Late

11 Guided By Voices – Nowhere To Go But Up

12 Bonnie “Prince” Billy – Keeping Secrets Will Destroy You

13 Swansea Sound – Twentieth Century

14 Kristin Hersh – Clear Pond Road

15 Brother Of Monday – Brother Of Monday

16 Craven Faults – Standers

17 R. Ring – War Poems, We Rested

18 Robert Forster – The Candle And The Flame

19 Oldfield Youth Club – The Hanworth Are Coming

20 Wurld Series – The Giant’s Lawn

21 Domenico Lancellotti – Sramba

22 Papernut Cambridge – Channel Suite

23 Guided By Voices – Welshpool Frillies

24 The Cleaners From Venus – K7

25 The Necks – Travel

…. and making up a top 50 albums, all of which you should own, are, in alphabetical order, 25 more:

Babybird – Dropping Dead Bouncing Back; Belbury Poly – The Path; Burning Ferns – World Of The Wars; Connections – Cool Change; Great Panoptique Winter – This Time Alone; The Handsome Family – Hollow; The Hermitts – Weight Of The World; Nabihah Iqbal – Dreamer; King Creosote – I Des; Jon Langford & The Men Of Gwent – Lost On Sea And Land; – Lankum – False Lankum; Lauds – Imitation Life; The Medusa Snare – What’s The Matter; Allan Murphy – Slow Life; Mythical Motors – Join Her Circus; The Reds, Pinks & Purples – The Town That Cursed Your Name; Sanam – Aykathani Malakon; Ryan Shirlow – Ullstair University Vol. 1; Sissy Space Echo & The Invisible Collaborators – From A Land Of Glass Without Mirrors; Smug Brothers – In The Book Of Bad Ideas; Soft Hearted Scientists – Waltz Of The Weekend; The Veils – …And Out Of The Void Came Love; Warrington-Runcorn New Town Development Plan – The Nation’s Most Central Location; Wreckless Eric – Leisureland; Veryan – Reflections In A Wilderness

Top 5 Compilations

1 Where Were You: Independent Music From Leeds (1978-1989 (Cherry Red)

2 Cool English Jumpsuit: A Tribute To Guided By Voices Circa 20 Something 13 And 14 (The Bert Dax Cavalcade Of Stars) /  Poor Substitutes: A Tribute To Ricked Wicky (The Bert Dax Cavalcade Of Stars)

3 In The Light of Time – UK Post-Rock & Leftfield Pop 1992-1998 (Ace Records)

4 Signals, Wires & Amplifiers 3 (Next Phase: Normal Records)

5 Lo Fi City Compilation 10

Top 5 EPs

1  The Reds, Pinks & Purples -Dust In The Path Of Love / You Know You’re Burning Someone / Unloveable Losers / Inner Richmond / Build Love / Murder, Oral Sex & Cigarettes / We Can’t All Be Heroes

Too many to chose from, so I’ve chosen them all. Really looking forward to the Leeds gig next summer.

2 Warrington-Runcorn New Town Development Plan – Building A New Town

3 David Boulter – Factory

4 The Wind-Up Birds – Pop.Thinking

5 Healing & Peace – Healing & Peace

Top 5 Reissues / Re-pressings / Remixes / Not Strictly Speaking New Stuff

1  Datblygu – Terfysgiaith 1982-2022

THE best Welsh band. This is a must have compilation for anyone who considers themselves a fan of independent outsider music. Also, another reason to learn Welsh, yn amlwg.

2 The Who – Who’s Next (50th Anniversary)

3 The Replacements – Tim (Let It Bleed Edition)

4 The Teardrop Explodes – Culture Bunker 1978-82

5 Art Fact – Tape Works 1986-1993

Top 5 Live Albums

1   The Nightingales – Live In Balsall Heath

No messing about between songs. This is The Nightingales in full flight.

2 Mr Anyway’s Holey Spirits – Mr Anyway’s Holey Spirits Perform! One Foot in Bethlehem

3 Spare Snare – The Brutal (Live)

4 Urusei Yatsura – Southampton Joiners Arms, 1996

5 Dexys – The Feminine Divine Live! – Official Bootleg: Liverpool Philharmonic Hall, Liverpool, 7 September

The Robert Pollard Annual Output Roundup

Guided By Voices released three new albums in 2023, taking it up to sixteen from the current line-up with La La Land, Welshpool Frillies, and Nowhere To Go But Up. We also had re-releases on Scat Records of Sandbox (in blue and black vinyl) and Self-Inflicted Aerial Nostalgia (in a couple of gorgeous yellow variants). We also had the very welcome return of Circus Devils with their album Squeeze The Needle and two tribute albums: Cool English Jumpsuit: A Tribute To Guided By Voices Circa 20 Something 13 And 14, and Poor Substitutes: A Tribute To Ricked Wicky both again curated by Bunnygrunt’s Matt Harnish. Perhaps most surprisingly we also had a second helping of Tobin Sprout‘s Demos & Outtakes with, er, Demos & Outtakes Two. Doug Gillard rightly made Rolling Stone magazine’s best guitarists of all-time list, but far to low down in my view, and he almost certainly appeared on loads of records that I have missed. Sorry about that.

The Stephen Jones One Man Domination Of Record Shelf Space Award

Just the 222 tracks released by Stephen Jones this year under various guises:

As Babybird we had the following seven albums: Bad Ideas, I **** Life, di’ sek-tid, To Express Happiness Without Sarcasm Is Impossible, Dropping Dead Bouncing Back (including a 4 disc version with the pictured painting), I Hate My Life But I Love Yours and, right at the end of the year, the now traditional Christmas album, this time being H**** Xmas. As Stephen Jones we were treated with Christmas: The Original Soundtrack (too late for last year’s list) and A Heartbreaking Album About Illness.

Top 2 Music Related Books (Read This Year)

Amy Rigby – Girl To City

John Cooper Clarke – I Wanna Be Yours (the highly recommended audiobook read by the Bard of Salford himself)

Other books I have read this year, including a fair few in Welsh, were:

Lois Arnold – Sgŵp***, Pamela Petro – Travels In An Old Tongue***, Wampus Reynolds – Way I See It**, Mick Herron – Standing By The Wall*, Dylan Thomas – Under Milk Wood**, Scott Murray – The Title**, Richard MacAndrew – Gêm Beryglus**, Mick Herron – Down Cemetary Road**, Pegi Talfryn – Cariad Pur*, Becca Brown – Gwers Mewn Cariad*, Evie King – Ashes To Admin**, JRR Tolkien – The Hobbit**, Helen Naylor – Y Llythyr**, Blake Morrison – As If***, Ewan Smith – Hen Ferchetan*, Zoe Pettinger – Croesi’r Bont*, Jacob Holm-Lupo – On Track: Blue Oyster Cult**, Mick Herron – Bad Actors**

Top 3 Music Films Seen (But Not Necessarily Released) This Year

1  Nothing Compares (Sinead O’Connor)

2  White Riot (Rock Against Racism)

3 Dexys Midnight Runners – Too-Rye-Aye Live

Musical Sources Of The Year

Werra Foxma Records

Sulk Rooms – Evie (Official Soundtrack); Dohnavur Remix Project; Werra Foxma Remixes Volume One; 4T Thieves – Nomad’s Requiem; Nyorai – Harukaze; John Haughey – Flowline; Ian Boddy – Coil; Swansither  – The Waken; Amongst The Pigeons – Embrace The Point Of No Return; Cognition Delay – Synapse Lapse; Yellow Belly – Spiral; Carter Takes A Train – Dronescape;

Top 5 Gigs

1 The Chills – The Deaf Institute, Manchester, 10 June

2 The Declining Winter + Epic45 – Mill Hill Chapel, Leeds, 26 November

3 Kristin Hersh – Philharmonic Music Room, Liverpool, 1 October

4 Robyn Hitchcock – Philharmonic Music Room, Liverpool, 28 February

5 Dexys – Philharmonic Hall, Liverpool, 7 September

Favourite Music Related Moments (Outside of Everything Above)

I may have mentioned this. The band I was involved in back in the late 80s released its first physicality this year, some 30 years on. You can read the full story here if you are so inclined.

You can also listen to, and buy(?!), all the tracks we released as Tom Violence / Redbrick Shithouse on Recordiau Prin (the CD has long gone, sadly)

But you can find more Tom Violence on Almost Halloween Time Records, where we still have vinyl available, housed in unique hand-painted numbered covers – explained here – and with proper musicians covering our best songs. Last year’s song of the year by Hercules Fence is now joined by Wio and Ed Nolbed as well as Jan off of Spare Snare re-editing a track too.

I also believe all the cool kids are wearing Tom Violence merch – we have very limited numbers still available here should you wish to join them.

Please help support all the wonderful musicians mentioned in the lists above by searching out their records, CDs, tapes and downloads and BUYING THEM!!!

Previous end of year podcasts:

Related articles:

Podcast 125: Chorizo’s Best of 2023

Seeing well over 150 bands in 2023 has had a major impact on Chorizo’s end of year selections and 15 of his 24 songs are by artists that he has seen live over the year. That’s 5 eighths for you fraction enthusiasts.

Check out what Chorizo and Kicker have to say about all that on part 1 here and part 2 over here.

Part 1

Part 2

Spoiler alert: don’t look below this picture if you don’t want to know the tracks we played.

Part 1:

Part 2:

Previous end of year podcasts:

Podcast 124: Kicker’s Best of 2023

In his annual round up, our Kicker narrows it down to his favourite 24 tracks of the year, split across two podcasts for your bitesize enjoyment.

Just click on the pictures to find a link to stream or download each half of the show or just directly listen on the players below them.

PART ONE:

PART TWO:

Turn away now if you don’t want to know what was played. Otherwise, here’s the run down:

Part 1 is tracks 1-12, Part 2 is tracks 13-24. Obviously.

  1. The The – $1 One Vote!
  2. R. Ring – Stole Eye
  3. Ed Nolbed – Everything
  4. The Hermitts – The Moors
  5. Guided By Voices – Released Into Dementia
  6. Circus Devils – Ferris Wheel
  7. Bonnie ‘Prince’ Billy – Willow, Pine And Oak
  8. James Yorkston – A Sweetness In You
  9. Brother Of Monday – Ken Tremendous
  10. Sparklehorse – Kind Ghosts
  11. Hap A Damwain – <1
  12. Elaine Howley – Picking Up The Pieces
  13. The Wind-Up Birds – Margarine
  14. Oldfield Youth Club – Cutbacks
  15. Robert Forster – Tender Years
  16. Graeme Jefferies – I Wish We Could Turn Back The Clock Like It’s 1978
  17. Swansea Sound – Markin’ It Down
  18. The Bug Club – Undone
  19. Sparks – When You Leave
  20. Wurld Series – Lord Of Shelves
  21. Kristin Hersh – Ms Haha
  22. Babybird – Untitled (A Dream)
  23. The Fragiles – When You’re Gone
  24. Spare Snare – That’s About It

The physicality (where there was some):

As always, we urge you to support all the wonderful musicians involved in making our lives more tolerable by seeking them out on bandcamp (using the links above where available) or elsewhere, and BUYING their stuff.

Streaming is for wimps. Thanks.

Previous End of Year Podcasts:

The Wedding Present in Leeds

This weekend I am going to see The Wedding Present in Leeds, the city where bandleader David Gedge was born. He actually grew up in Middleton, just north of Manchester on the other side of the Pennines. But later he returned to the city of his birth to attend Leeds University and that’s where the band were formed. The cassette version of their debut album “George Best” I had as a teenager proudly displayed the catalogue number LEEDS1C.

This will be the 5th time I’ve seen The Wedding Present in 2023 and they have recently overtaken Elvis Costello as the artist I’ve seen the most times.

The Leeds gig will be the 34th time I’ve seen them and to celebrate this milestone I’ve made this lovely bar chart. The colour scheme is based on the “Bizarro” album cover which was released the week before I first saw them at Kilburn National Ballroom.

The most I’ve seen them at the same venue is 3 times at The Live Rooms in Chester. When they played there in June this year, David said how much he likes the venue so hopefully I’ll be seeing them there again soon.

There are quite a few venues where I’ve seen them twice: Liverpool Academy 2, Sheffield Leadmill, Manchester Academy, Manchester Ritz, Holmfirth Picturedrome and Concorde 2 in Brighton.

Technically I saw them twice at another venue in Brighton but I don’t know if that counts. That’s because it was called Top Rank for the gig I went to in 1990 but by the time I saw them there again in 1992 it had changed its name to The Event. Exactly the same venue though.

The 4 times I’ve seen them in London have all been at different venues: The Forum, Cadogan Hall and the much-missed Astoria and Kilburn National Ballroom. I also saw them at Dingwalls at one of the Camden Crawls in the mid 90s too, but I only caught the last couple of songs so I’ve not counted it.

Some data analysis carried out via setlist.fm seems to point towards “Brassneck” being the song I’ve heard them play the most times. Here’s a video of them playing that from the Liverpool gig I went to last year. Filmed by the semi-legendary “seajohnster” who attends way more Wedding Present gigs than I do and has shedloads of amazing live videos on his Youtube channel.

In case anyone’s interested here are the 12 bands I’ve seen the most times:

  • 34 – The Wedding Present (first time 1989, most recent 2023)
  • 31 – Elvis Costello (first time 1989, most recent 2022)
  • 21 – Billy Bragg (first time 1987, most recent 2019)
  • 14 – Tindersticks (first time 1993, most recent 2022)
  • 13 – Nick Cave (first time 1990, most recent 2021)
  • 12 – Manic Street Preachers (first time 1994, most recent 2019)
  • 11 – The Wave Pictures (first time 2015, most recent 2023)
  • 11 – PJ Harvey (first time 1992, most recent 2023)
  • 10 – Super Furry Animals (first time 1996, most recent 2015)
  • 9 – Radiohead (first time 1995, most recent 2017)
  • 7 – Joe Strummer (first time 1988, most recent 2001😢)
  • 7 – Thousand Yard Stare (first time 1991, most recent 2017)

For the full origin story of how I became an obsessive Wedding Present fan, read this article which was included in the recent book about the band “All The Songs Sounds The Same” [buy it here]

More Wedding Present articles on this website:

Wedding Present live reviews on this website:

Podcast episodes where we have played The Wedding Present / Cinerama songs:

Robert Pollard’s Guide To The 60s – Tape 35: Flamingo / Teenage Head – The Flamin’ Groovies

Proper rock ‘n roll comin’ straight atchew from San Franciso with the apostrophe friendly Flamin’ Groovies and a couple of their albums released around 1970. Uncle Bob omitted to name the albums on his list of tapes, so we’ve had a guess at what he might have been listenin’ to.

You can find out what we made of these albums by clickin’ on the image below and tunin’ in to us talkin’.

Our chats about the previous tapes can be found where you found this one.

To avoid any potential disappointment on missin’ out on the next show, make sure you follow our podcast on Spotify or subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

Robert Pollard’s Guide To The 60s – Tape 34: Hey Little One – Glen Campell / Petula – Petula Clark

We delve into the world of pop (with added strings) on this episode and consider the relative merits of albums by two musicians who became TV stars, but only one of whom covered Guided By Voices.

You can find out what we made of these albums by Glen Campbell and Petula Clark by clicking on the image below.

Our chats about the previous tapes can be found where you found this one.

To avoid any potential disappointment on missing out on the next show, make sure you follow our podcast on Spotify or subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

28 album reviews in 28 days #MWE

[Just found this in my drafts, written way back in March 2021]

I’ve just finished the #MWE challenge for February. This stands for “Music Writer Exercise” and the challenge is to listen to an album you have never heard before each day and write a one tweet review of it.

Last year I participated in the voting for this “100 Greatest Albums of the 21st Century” list. When the results were published I noticed that not only did nearly all of my choices fail to make the list but also that there were an awful lot of albums listed that I’d never heard. So I chose 28 of them to listen to one per day throughout February.

Pretty much as soon as I started I realised that the most difficult part wasn’t listening to the albums but trying to cram your thoughts about it into 280 characters!

Here’s the list with my ratings.

5 ***** = Absolutely love this!

4 **** = These are also great

3 *** = Like these, will definitely listen again

2 ** = Pretty good, might listen again.

1 * = 1 or 2 decent songs but won’t listen again

0 = No thank you, not for me

1st February: Come On Feel The Illinoise by Sufjan Stevens (2005) 3***

A lot to take in here! 22 songs! Strings brass woodwind! A 5/4 song that sounds like The Cure’s Close To Me! Banjos! Lovely backing vocals! Another song in 5/4! Steve Reich-y closer! Quite overwhelming on the 1st listen but I’ll definitely revisit.

2nd February: Have You In My Wilderness by Julia Holter (2015) 1*

2 listens of this today, definitely better on headphones than in the car. Both times I had (but resisted!) the urge to press skip on 1 jazzy/weird song (Vasquez) Much preferred the gentler orchestral songs e.g. Night Song, title track

3rd February: And Then Nothing Turned Itself Inside Out by Yo La Tengo (2000) 3***

Hammond organ, slow tempos, atmospheric instrumental parts, brushed drums. Given my Tindersticks obsession, perhaps no surprise that I really liked this! Standout track Tears Are In Your Eyes. Will definitely revisit.

4th February: Suburban Light by The Clientele (2000) 2**

Well, this is very pleasant. Digging the 60s chord sequences & occasional backwards guitar. Loved the vocals too, apart from the falsetto bits. I especially liked the songs that reminded me of the slower songs on VU & Nico Andy Warhol LP 🍌

5th February: Things We Lost In The Fire by Low (2001) 3***

Already know & ❤️ 2 later albums & saw them in 2016 where they played 1 song off this apparently. Mimi’s voice is wonderful. Alan’s on its own can get a bit too whiney Neil Young sometimes. But when they harmonise together it’s paradise.

6th February: Halcyon Digest by Deerhunter (2010) 4****

Didn’t like the slow track Sailing, possibly because I was listening while running? But all the rest is bloody great. Highlights include the sax on Coronado, the weird electronic percussion & the strange lyrics throughout. Another to revisit.

7th February: Tender Buttons by Broadcast (2005) 1*

My least favourite so far. Not that it’s terrible, it’s fine but it’s nothing more than that. Occasionally threatens to get interesting but mostly just background music, I kept almost forgetting that it was on. Stereolab without the melodies.

8th February: Teen Dream by Beach House (2010) 2**

Love the lead vocalist here & lots of cool understated guitar/keyboard lines. Mazzy Star meets The Shins. Sure I’ve heard the track Norway somewhere before? Bit of a dip in quality in the middle but first 3 songs are good & the last 3 even better.

9th February: Oceans Apart by The Go Betweens (2005) 4****

A definite hit. Bright & tuneful, a nice change after some of the recent albums. Enjoyed the Marr-like open string chords on Boundary Rider & the gradual build of Finding You. Now That’s What I Call Proper Songwriting.

10th February: Vampire Weekend by Vampire Weekend (2008) 1*

Exciting, consistently interesting & sounds like great fun to jump around to. Liked the Afrobeat / ska elements but ultimately it’s a young man’s game this. If I’d been 17 in 2008, this would be one of my favourite albums of all time!

11th February: Channel Orange by Frank Ocean (2012) 2**

Lots of it seems to be about unrequited love & existential longing. Frank’s like an emo Prince. Snip off a few songs at either end to improve it because all the best stuff’s in the middle (Sweet Life, Pyramids, Lost, White, Monks, Bad Religion)

12th February: Want One by Rufus Wainwright (2003) 4****

Ballads are good obviously because of that voice. But what really sweeps me away here are the grandiose everything-including-several-kitchen-sinks epics. Amazing arrangements, production, performances. Favourite song I Don’t Know What It Is

13th February: Lift Your Skinny Fists Like Antennas To Heaven by Godspeed You! Black Emperor (2000) 5*****

It’s Sigur Ros minus the annoying singing. 4 tracks each around 20 minutes. Paced like a Mahler symphony but enhanced by the beautiful, beautiful sound of guitar feedback. I’m going to buy this one.

14th February: Madvilliany by Madvillain (2004) 3***

Very creative sampling going on, all kinds of weird musical genres going off in the background. I like the GZA style laid-back wasted delivery of the rhymes too. Densely packed wordplay, need to listen again to get my head round what it all means.

15th February: The Silver Globe by Jane Weaver (2014) 5*****

In which Jane weaves(!) together electronica, kosmische, disco, folk & synthpop to make a wonderfully comfortable but occasionally itchy blanket. But it’s her versatile singing voice that’s holding the metaphorical blanket together.

16th February: Kiwanuka by Michael Kiwanuka (2019) 3***

Really liked his previous album & saw him live at The Ritz in Manchester in 2016. This is more of the same really, Danger Mouse producing again so naturally I like this too. Highlights from 1st listen: Piano Joint, Hard To Say Goodbye, Light.

17th February: Time (The Revelator) by Gillian Welch (2001) 3***

Great voice & plays a mean banjo. I love Dear Someone, could’ve been written by Hank himself! Last track I Dream A Highway WOW! A sad tale of yearning involving Johnny Cash, Emmylou & Gram over the same 3 chords for 14 hypnotic minutes.

18th February: Master and Everyone by Bonnie Prince Billy (2003) 0

Disappointing! Based on other songs of his I’ve heard & enjoyed, I was expecting interesting characters & stories, maybe a bit of dark humour. If there was any of that here, then it totally passed me by. [I think I was confusing Bonnie Prince Billy with Bill Callahan here]

19th February: Diamond Mine by King Creosote & Jon Hopkins (2011) 2**

Acoustic melancholia with added bleeps & crackles. The harmonium bits remind me of Ivor Cutler without the jokes. Definitely intrigued enough to go back for another listen, even though this makes me miss holidays in Scotland.😐

20th February: Tomorrow’s Harvest by Boards Of Canada (2013) 1*

Ominous synths & beats. Sounds like the soundtrack to an unnecessarily graphic 1980s public information film discouraging children from playing with farm equipment. Might listen again but only as background music while I’m working.

21st February: Not The Trembling Kind by Laura Cantrell (2000) 2**

Old school country sung beautifully, mostly quite low-key & acoustic with wonderful mandolin & lap steel accompaniment. Reminded me of Nanci Griffith which is a very good thing. Favourite songs Queen of the Coast, Somewhere Some Night

22nd February: The Woods by Sleater Kinney (2005) 4****

Made a nice change to listen to SOMETHING REALLY LOUD after several days of gentle albums. How did this band pass me by at the time? 11 minute thrashathon Let’s Call It Love is either the best or worst song here, need more listens to decide which.

23rd February: Donuts by J Dilla (2006) 4****

Disappointingly there’s no rapping about donuts here, no rapping at all in fact. Lots of King Tubby sci-fi sound fx, 70s soul samples & wonky-sounding breakbeats. Reminds me of Nightmares On Wax which means Donuts🍩 is my “jam”!😂 “Ring” the Alarm!🤣

24th February: Rounds by Four Tet (2003) 2**

More downtempo trip-hoppy instrumental stuff with some great melodies floating about. Favourite track: My Angel Rocks Back & Forth, cool harp sample makes it sound like Bjork’s Vespertine. This is another album I might listen to again as background music.

25th February: Norman Fucking Rockwell by Lana Del Rey (2019) 5*****

Seeing as I’ve started with some swearing let’s carry on, this is absolutely fucking brilliant. Whoever she’s singing about here, please go to California ASAP because Lana’s missing you & she REALLY wants to dance with you.

26th February: Dragging A Dead Deer Up A Hill by Grouper (2008) 0

Mazzy Star played at the wrong speed. Don’t hear anything that explains why people have listed this in their favourite albums of the century. Possibly it’d improve with repeated listens but I won’t be taking the time to find out.

27th February: Any Other City by Life Without Buildings (2001) 4****

Vocalist Wow! She’s doing that talking/singing/shouting thing, reminds me of Flowered Up, X Ray Spex, Fontaines DC,@EddieArgos, Blue Aeroplanes & the incomprehensible stream of consciousness chatter of Hybrid in Battlestar Galactica.

28th February: The Drift by Scott Walker (2006) 0

Not sure I hear a single. Very unpredictable with many dynamic shifts from quiet to loud keeping you on your toes & I didn’t expect either the braying donkeys or the Donald Duck impressions! Hard work though, I’ll stick to The Lights Of Cincinatti!

Here is a playlist I made as I went along with some favourite songs from each album (except the 0 ranking ones!)

More on Twitter

Robert Pollard’s Guide To The 60s – Tape 33: The Twain Shall Meet – Eric Burdon & The Animals / Fun House – The Stooges

Two very different albums under scrutiny in this show. One, from the height of the hippie dream, full of optimism and naivety, the other its brutal and violent opposite.

Guess which one we liked best.

You can find out what we made of these albums by clicking on the image below.

Our chats about the previous tapes can be found where you found this one.

To avoid any potential disappointment on missing out on the next show, make sure you follow our podcast on Spotify or subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

Scottish albums road trip

Last month I had a lovely family holiday in Scotland with Mrs Garbanzo & the 2 Garbanzo Juniors. Oh, and Nova the dog.

Nova at the top of The Knock, Perthshire

We decided (well, let’s be honest I decided) that we would only listen to albums by Scottish artists in the car.

A few weeks before going, I posted a first draft of my list on Twitter or whatever that nobhead Musk is calling it now.

I was very surprised to get more than 400 replies to that list. Those mostly fell into these 7 categories:

  • people helpfully suggesting bands that weren’t on the list because I had forgotten about them (e.g. The Shop Assistants, Sons & Daughters) or because I hadn’t actually realised they were Scottish (e.g. This Mortal Coil)
  • people helpfully suggesting bands that I’d already thought of but not decided not to include on the list because I just don’t happen to like them very much (e.g. Simple Minds, Primal Scream, Del Amitri, Sensational Alex Harvey Band)
  • people who hadn’t read my list properly saying “OMG I can’t believe you haven’t included…” & then suggesting a band that were already on the list
  • people who hadn’t read my Tweet properly suggesting new upcoming bands who haven’t made an album yet
  • people trying to outdo each by naming more and more obscure bands
  • actual bands putting themselves forward for inclusion (hi there This Poison!)
  • people slating off my list saying it was terrible, but not deigning themselves to suggest any bands that would improve it

Armed now with the helpful suggestions, I made a list of 120 albums. I limited the list to only 1 or 2 albums by nearly all the artists. But a few exceptions to that rule were permitted.

The Proclaimers and Mike Scott / The Waterboys are already well-established Garbanzo family favourites so they both had loads of albums in the list. Same for Cocteau Twins because they are one of Mrs Garbanzo’s favourite bands of all time.

The list was sorted in alphabetical order by album title and numbered accordingly. Then we used a random number generator to decide which album to listen to next.

Each family member (but not the dog) was given 2 “joker” cards which could be brought into play at any time in the holiday. Playing a joker would mean that the random number part was skipped and they could just choose any album from the list.

Good advice on the window of Stirling Boys Club

Big thanks to the elder of my 2 sons (Chorizo Junior The Elder) who very kindly wrote down all the albums we listened to in a notebook. He also noted down any particular favourite songs which I’ve put in a Spotify playlist at the bottom of the page.

We ended up having to impose an informal rationing of “favourite songs” to prevent every song on certain albums from being included (e.g. Blue Bell Knoll, This Is The Sea)

There were no Teenage Fanclub albums included on the list because Chorizo Junior The Elder and I are going to see them in Manchester soon and we have recently completed a separate project where we have listened to all their albums in order of release (another blog post incoming on that soon!)

Main conclusion to be drawn from this experiment:

The 2 boys definitely don’t share their parents’ enthusiasm for Cocteau Twins but they absolutely love the surreal songs and poetry of Ivor Cutler. And none of my family are anywhere near as keen on jangly 80s indie-pop as I am.

Here’s a list of the albums in the order we listened to them:

  • Dreamland – Aztec Camera
  • Let’s Get Out Of This Country – Camera Obscura
  • Heavy Elevator – Hamish Hawk
  • Day Of The Lone Wolf – Astrid Williamson
  • Black Bay – Silver Moth
  • Any Other City – Life Without Buildings
  • Charm – Spare Snare
  • Heavy Heavy – Young Fathers (Joker card played by Chorizo Junior The Elder)
  • Fisherman’s Blues – The Waterboys
  • The Glasgow School – Orange Juice (Joker card played by me)
  • Treasure – Cocteau Twins
  • The Bones Of What You Believe – Chvrches (Joker card played by Chorizo Junior The Younger)
  • Foxheads Stalk This Land – Close Lobsters
  • Run Around The Sun – Sacred Paws
  • Born Innocent – The Proclaimers
  • Dear Catastrophe Waitress – Belle & Sebastian
  • A Flat Man – Ivor Cutler
  • Will Anything Happen – The Shop Assistants
  • All Souls Hill – The Waterboys
  • Bring ‘Em All In – Mike Scott
  • Young Forever – Aberfeldy (played because we were driving through Aberfeldy)
  • The Wringer – Martha Ffion
  • Still Burning – Mike Scott (Joker card played by Mrs Garbanzo)
  • Home Again – Edwyn Collins
  • This Is The Sea – The Waterboys (Joker card played by Chorizo Junior The Elder)
  • In My Mind There’s A Room – Mull Historical Society
  • Angel Numbers – Hamish Hawk
  • Four Calendar Cafe – Cocteau Twins
  • Magazine – This Poison!
  • One Head Two Arms Two Legs – Dawn Of The Replicants
  • The Greatest Hits – Texas
  • Blue Bell Knoll – Cocteau Twins (Joker card played by Mrs Garbanzo)
  • Pinky Blue – Altered Images
  • Gorgeous George – Edwyn Collins
  • The Crossing – Big Country
  • Notes & Rhymes – The Proclaimers
  • The Private Memories & Confessions Of – The Just Joans (Joker card played by me)
  • A Guide For The Daylight Hours – Ballboy
  • Lyceum – The Orchids
  • This Is The Story – The Proclaimers
  • The Making Of You – Snowgoose
  • Dandruff – Ivor Cutler (Joker card played by Chorizo Junior The Younger)

A handful of other albums we also listened to that I forgot to include in the pictures above:

  • Sunshine On Leith – The Proclaimers
  • An A To Z Of – Spare Snare (tracklist selected by my podcast co-host Kicker Of Elves)
  • Lagoon Blues – The Bathers
  • Jump – Paul Vickers & The Leg
  • Mrs Garbanzo’s Spotify playlist of Calvin Harris “bangers”
Nova enjoying a paddle in Loch Morlich

Apologies to these bands who had albums on the list but their numbers never came up:

  • Mogwai
  • This Mortal Coil
  • Kathryn Joseph
  • James Yorkston
  • Girobabies
  • Goya Dress
  • The Jesus & Mary Chain
  • Eddi Reader / Fairground Attraction
  • Geneva
  • Withered Hand
  • The Associates
  • Trashcan Sinatras
  • Eugenius
  • Dogs Die In Hot Cars
  • The Soup Dragons
  • Strawberry Switchblade
  • Skerryvore
  • Bronski Beat
  • The Delgados
  • Travis
  • Frightened Rabbit
  • Josef K
  • Urusei Yatsura
  • Sons & Daughters
  • Bis

Here’s the playlist of favourite songs from the albums we listened to.

View from the A93 near Glenshee

Related posts:

The Top by The Cure

Here’s an article I wrote for a recent “The Cure Special” issue of the fanzine Lunchtime For The Wild Youth.

Fanzine editor Russell says about the issue:

“Enjoy this trip through the back catalogue of albums, plus one compilation, Steve’s piece on seeing them live at Crystal Palace Bowl, a gig I was at myself (see issue 3) and an extract from John Robb’s book The Art Of Darkness.”

I chose to write about the album that was my introduction to The Cure in 1984. (You can buy the whole fanzine for an absolute bargain £1 here)

Some of those articles where they rank a particular groups albums or songs, you know the ones, can really get under my skin. I suspect they only exist as clickbait anyway, tempting the reader to share it with their friends saying “Have you seen this list of best songs by Snotty & The Nosepickers? What a load of bollocks!” When said friend reads it, it registers as another hit on the website and everyone’s a winner.

The Top is often an unfairly demeaned victim of this kind of article. Received wisdom seems to place it very low in the rankings of “Best Cure albums in the world EVER!!!1!!1!” Usually it’s placed lower than any other album from the band’s “imperial phase” which the mass of critical and public opinion seems to define as running from the first album up to the early 1990s.

It’s perhaps not difficult to see how The Top has ended up being dismissed as the unloved stepchild of the bands albums from that period. It’s partly due to its chronological place in the band’s discography.  It was preceded by the majestic “goth” trilogy Seventeen Seconds / Faith / Pornography. Those were the only albums recorded by the Smith / Tolhurst / Gallup trio and they share a similar sound palette. They gave us spindly guitar lines, breathy synths, drums heavy on the tom toms, drum machines heavy on the snare and very prominent bass guitar parts. You could take any song from those 3 albums and swap it to one of the other albums without it sounding particularly out of place.

Then you’ve got the most commercially successful albums that followed after The Top, the albums that generally feature right at the top in the online rankings and include nearly all the band’s best-known songs (The Head On The DoorKiss Me Kiss Me Kiss Me Kiss MeDisintegration and Wish, each one of those a multi-million seller.)

So The Top sits awkwardly sandwiched between those 2 more easily digested eras. Here’s an extract from “Cured,” the brilliant book by Lol Tolhurst: “This was The Cure Mark 2. This version was more expansive and less stripped down than the previous iteration, the Pornography Cure, as it were.”

Simon Gallup had parted ways with The Cure by now after a notorious punch-up with Smith in Strasbourg and a fractious final gig in Brussels. The Cure were effectively now down to just two, Smith and his childhood pal Tolhurst. They took a left-turn into out-and-out pop music with their 3 singles in 1982/1983, Let’s Go To BedThe Walk and The Love Cats, scoring actual big hit singles with those last 2 making it to number 12 and number 7 respectively. Aged 12 and an avid listener to the Top 40, The Love Cats was the first time I can remember hearing The Cure. With its jazzy double bass and piano chords, it stood out as something very different from the rest of the charts just as much as it stands out from every other song in The Cure’s entire career. They would never again record a song that sounds like something from the soundtrack of the Disney film The Aristocats and as fun as that song is, most would probably agree that’s very much for the best.

Meanwhile Robert Smith was also playing with Siouxsie & The Banshees. When Siouxsie & Budgie went off to record as The Creatures and flirted with their own jazz tendencies, Smith teamed up with his new bassplaying pal Steve Severin and vocalist / dancer Jeanette Landray as The Glove and recorded the album Blue Sunshine going in an altogether different musical direction. Blue Sunshine is as bizarre and psychedelic as you’d expect an album recorded whilst binging on hallucinogens and old B-movies to be and it sounds like a bit of a stepping stone between Pornography and The Top.

Like many 13 year olds I used to record my favourite songs from the Top 40 countdown onto a tape for re-listening later and I loved the “do do do” chorus of The Caterpillar and its scrapy violin noises. For such a peculiar song, it’s incredibly catchy and I loved it so much I bought the 7” single. A little while after that, I discovered that my local library in Haslemere lent out tapes so I could use my elder brother’s fancy new JVC tape-to-tape player to make my own copies. (Incidentally, that library is just 8 miles from Chestnut Studios where The Cure recorded their first demos.)

Me with my 7″ of The Caterpillar

So I soon ended up with a C90 that had Echo & The Bunnymen’s Ocean Rain on one side and The Top on the other. There was even room to fit on the b-side of my Caterpillar single Happy The Man. So many joyful teenage hours spent listening to both sides of that tape.

Happy The Man, like the whole of The Top, is quite a peculiar little thing. Another extract from Lol Tolhurst’s book: “There was always a psychedelic side to Robert that he explored in depth on The Top¸ which to all intents and purposes is a psychedelic album, albeit a couple of decades after the original psychedelic era.” In the spirit of that original era, it’s also genuinely experimental and just quite odd. Maybe that’s another reason why it doesn’t get the praise that other Cure albums from around that time do? It’s unpigeonholeable.

The album kicks off aggressively with crashing drums and waves of guitar on Shake Dog Shake. One of many songs on this album where the lyrics are coming from quite a dark place, “anger” “spit” “cough” “scrape my skin with razor blades” before we’ve even made it to the first chorus! Over the coming years, this song would be played live way more than any other from this album and quite often as the opening song (including in the brilliant Live At Orange film.) It’s the only song from The Top that’s being played on the current US tour and they’ve played it pretty much every night. Shake shake shake shake shake shake shake shake shake shake shake shake shake dog shake!

Bird Mad Girl starts with acoustic guitars, a relative rarity on The Cure’s album up until this point. There are bits of piano and various percussion, including the staple of every primary school music lesson, the claves. It’s another incredibly catchy song, one of my favourites on the album. It feels a bit like a companion piece to Mr. Alphabet Says, one of only 2 songs on the Blue Sunshine album where Smith sings the lead vocals (and also to Six Different Ways on The Head On The Door.)

Similarly, Wailing Wall with its Eastern-tinged melody and cymbals shares some of its sound with a song by The Glove (Orgy) as well as a Cure song from a future album (If Only Tonight We Could Sleep from Kiss Me Kiss Me Kiss Me.)

Yet more dark and aggressive lyrics to kick off Give Me It: “get away from me, get your fingers out of my face” (Smith still annoyed about the punch-up with Gallup??) Layers of squealing lead guitar and drums that are almost proto-“baggy” it’s definitely the heaviest song they’d recorded so far in their career, and arguably wouldn’t get this heavy again until the 2000s.

The pace drops for Dressing Up, a lovely gentle song that’s almost entirely synth-based. Listen to it on headphones and there’s just so much going on here. Smith wrote this one about putting on make-up & getting ready for a gig. He told Rolling Stone that it was “actually done as a Glove song, and then I didn’t play it to (Steve) Severin because I thought, I like this one too much.”

After The Caterpillar (still flickering, still beautiful on every listen and still in my top 3 Cure songs) comes Piggy In The Mirror, another of my favourites on the album. It’s a superb song with a memorable melody, a great organ part and a charming acoustic guitar solo. Just when you think it’s coming to end, here comes the coda as Smith sings “as I dance, dance back” and repeats the songtitle over the syncopated synth riff. Just brilliant. Once again, there’s a song on Blue Sunshine that sounds like a bit of a pre-cursor to this, the dizzying This Green City with its distorted twisting guitar and woodwind-like synths lurking in the background.

There’s more of those woodwind synth sounds on the next track The Empty World which starts off with military drums to match the lyrics “she talked about the armies that marched inside her head.” Smith has described this song as “the flip side to Charlotte Sometimes” and the female subjects of both songs appear to be struggling to distinguish between fantasy and reality.

Partly inspired by a short story by J.D. Salinger “A perfect day for Bananafish” there’s a great singalong chorus on Bananafishbones: “Oh kill me kiss me once and then we’ll throw it away” Had they chosen to release a second single from this album, then I think this would’ve been a good choice. It’s another song that sounds straightforward, but when you listen on headphones there’s so many interesting little melodic hooks to reel you in. A bouncy synth bassline, some great Hammond organ sounds and at least 3 different guitar parts contrasting with each other.

The album closes with the title track The Top, just under 7 minutes long and comfortably the longest song on the album. There’s a recording of a spinning top at the start followed by very sparse verses with a weirdly dissonant bass riff. The lyrics of the chorus take us back into the world of fantasy (“this top is the place where nobody goes, you just imagine, you just imagine it all”) but the music that accompanies those words is strangely uplifting, as if yearning for a peaceful resolution to all the confusion and conflict that has gone before.

So there it is. Ten very diverse songs, none sounding quite like the others, none sounding quite like anything The Cure had released up to this point.

And all of it has come from the mind of just One Imaginary Boy.

More than any other album, this is the closest we have ever got to hearing a Robert Smith solo album. Apart from Andy Anderson’s drumming, you’ve got Lol Tolhurst’s keyboards on just 3 songs. Porl Thompson, who would later join as full-time guitarist, plays the saxophone on Give Me It. Apart from that, every single sound you hear is played by Robert Smith, who himself described The Top as “the solo album I never made.”

My affection for this album grew even stronger after I went to see The Cure at the Hammersmith Odeon on 22nd December 2014. Taken from the band’s announcement of these gig dates: “The band will be performing a 150 minute show playing songs drawn from their entire 37 year old catalogue including deep cuts, pop songs, fan favourites and surprises galore.” The band And Also The Trees were supporting, just as they had done at the same venue when The Cure had first played it 30 years earlier.

Every other Cure gig I’ve been to has been either a festival or in an arena / enormodome, so I didn’t want to miss the opportunity to see them in a more intimate venue. If the reference to the 1984 Odeon gigs was a clue to what they would be playing then it went completely over my head at the time so I was both excited and surprised when after opening the gig with 2 of my favourite songs from The Top (Shake Dog Shake, Piggy In The Mirror) Robert revealed that in celebration of the 30th anniversary of their first gig at that venue, they would be playing all the songs from The Top during the set. Re-fucking-sult!!

The Cure @ Hammersmith Odeon, 22nd December 2014. (Photo by my wife)

That Hammersmith gig is a very special memory and definitely my favourite of all The Cure gigs I’ve been to, in no small part because I got to hear the whole of the album that made me a fan in the first place!

Just look at this 40 song setlist (songs from The Top underlined) …

Shake Dog Shake / Piggy in the Mirror / A Night Like This / Push / In Between Days / Just Like Heaven / Bananafishbones / The Caterpillar / The Walk / A Man Inside My Mouth / Wailing Wall /Three Imaginary Boys / Never Enough / Wrong Number / Birdmad Girl / Lovesong / Like Cockatoos / From the Edge of the Deep Green Sea / Kyoto Song / alt.end / Want / The Hungry Ghost / One Hundred Years / Give Me It / The Top

Encore 1: The Empty World / Charlotte Sometimes / Primary

Encore 2: M / Play for Today / A Forest

Encore 3: Pictures of You / Lullaby / Fascination Street

Encore 4: Dressing Up / The Lovecats / Close to Me / Why Can’t I Be You? / Boys Don’t Cry / Hey You!!!

You Should Always Keep In Touch With Your Friends (extract from The Wedding Present book “All The Songs Sound The Same”)

Earlier this year, a new book about The Wedding Present called “All The Songs Sound The Same” was released.

It is packed with hundreds of people writing about their favourite Wedding Present / Cinerama song and what it means to them. Lots of current and former bandmembers are included and it was lovingly curated by Richard Houghton and David Gedge himself. Many others provided their own stories for the book. Famous fans such as radio presenters Shaun Keaveney and Andrew Collins and the probable next Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer, alongside many less-celebrated ordinary proles like me.

You can buy the book from the band’s website here.

Here’s the piece I contributed to the book about the song “You Should Always Keep In Touch With Your Friends”…

Sheffield (February 2018)

It’s the Tommy 30th anniversary tour. I’m there with my oldest friends Mike, Rich and Simon and David Gedge has just dedicated a song to the 4 of us. As another David once sang “you may ask yourself, well how did I get here?”

The Wedding Present at The Leadmill, Sheffield (3rd February 2018)

West Sussex (30 years earlier)

If you know anything about Sussex, it won’t be anything to do with the unexciting top left corner of it where I grew up. All the best-known places like Brighton, Eastbourne and Hastings are in East Sussex. The only famous location in West Sussex is Gatwick and that is right in the opposite corner! The Cure’s hometown of Crawley is over that way too, which made them our not-that-local heroes.

The repetitive strain of our uneventful teenage lives was thankfully enlivened when we started going to watch gigs. The London to Portsmouth train line ran nearby which meant we could get to gigs in both of those, but only if we could persuade someone to take and collect us from the train station. Once we were old enough to learn to drive ourselves, a whole new set of possibilities opened up before us like a vast New Jersey freeway. Access to cars meant freedom, we were inside a Bruce Springsteen song. What else can we do now except roll down the window and let the wind blow back our hair because the night’s busting open and this dual carriageway can take us anywhere. Well, maybe not anywhere but Aldershot, Brighton and Reading were good enough for us. 

We were disciples of the gospel according to NME and Melody Maker and Janice Long’s weekday evenings show on Radio 1 was our holy communion. (I didn’t discover John Peel until a couple of years later) 

So it came to pass that in 1987, I sent off for a compilation tape advertised in Melody Maker called Indie Top Twenty. It’s not overstating it to say that tape changed my life. It was the first time I ever heard Half Man Half Biscuit, still one of my favourite bands to this day. It was the first time I heard Joy Division (unless you count the Love Will Tear Us Apart cover that was on Paul Young’s No Parlez which you definitely shouldn’t!)

It was the first time I’d heard The Blue Aeroplanes. Within 6 months, I would be singing and playing guitar in my own band with our name taken from a Blue Aeroplanes lyric and ending most of our gigs with a very loud and sped-up Joy Division cover. Have that, Paul Young! 

The tape was a gateway into so much more music and looking at the tracklisting I can see that in the aftermath of hearing it, I subsequently bought records or tapes by 16 of the 20 bands on it.

Most significantly, it was the first time I ever heard The Wedding Present and the song You Should Always Keep In Touch With Your Friends. 

The frantically strummed noisy guitars grabbed my attention but the lyrics seemed to be telling an altogether more melancholy tale. A lost, or more probably unrequited, love with a friend from school. 

On another record I love from that time, Billy Bragg said, “I couldn’t stop thinking about her and every time I switched on the radio there was somebody else singing a song about the two of us.”  

When you’re sixteen, clumsy and shy with hormones running riot and heightening every emotion to what often seems like unbearable levels, it feels like every short-term crush is actually “Love Story” and you can hear references to the sad little non-event that you laughingly call a lovelife in all manner of unlikely places. 

So those lyrics really said something to me about my life in 1987. A school trip to the unlikely destination of Ostend had provided me with a precious opportunity to spend a few hours talking to someone else’s girlfriend. That afternoon was the inspiration behind several of my own most cringeworthy attempts at lyric writing but I never came up with anything remotely as good as “a bridge that stood close by the sea, the day that we spent there is ours eternally.”

I bought Volume 2 of the Indie Top 20 tape when that came out. That had My Favourite Dress on it and I loved that just as much. The next few Wedding Present singles bedazzled us further.  Nobody’s Twisting Your Arm was a dancefloor staple at our favourite indie disco (Sister Rays in Brighton) as were the next singles Why Are You Being So Reasonable Now? and especially Kennedy. Just after that came out, we saw them live for the first time at Kilburn National Ballroom and a couple of months later we were back for more at Brighton Top Rank. 

Bizarro…  Seamonsters… Hit Parade… the noisy guitars got noisier, the records got even better, the gigs got wilder. Over the next few years, we saw them many more times in Portsmouth, Reading, Brighton and London. 

But as people do when they get older, gradually we all dispersed. By the end of 1992 when we saw them play in Brighton, none of us were living in Sussex. The venue itself had been renamed from Top Rank to The Event. The times they were a-changing. Over the next few years, various circumstances caused us to make our homes in all manner of glamorous locations… Tokyo! London! Sydney! Istanbul! Auckland! Sheffield! Liverpool! Swindon! Portsmouth! Chippenham! Cheam!

Holmfirth (August 2010)

Jobs, partners, children and the kind of responsibilities that go with being an actual grown-up followed and by 2010, the 4 of us have somehow ended up living almost at opposite corners of England. I’m in the North West. We were all 40 in 2010 and I noticed that a few days before my birthday The Wedding Present were playing in Holmfirth, about an hour’s drive from my front door. What’s more they’re celebrating the 21st anniversary of Bizarro by playing the album in full. 

A couple of years before, we had been to see the reformed Pogues at Brixton Academy and had spent most of the gig watching from near the back drinking our pints and discussing whether it was sensible to go down the front and get in amongst it. Were we too old to mosh? It’s a young man’s game, isn’t it. Eventually we’d had enough beer to give it a try anyway and those sweaty last 20 minutes were the best bit of the gig by a mile!

Having survived that, we knew how we wanted to celebrate the big 4-zero. Go to Holmfirth and laugh heartily in the face of the aging process by jumping around like lunatics down the front and pretending we were 19 again!

That Holmfirth gig was a bit of a Damascene moment for all of us. We realised that we needed to treasure every opportunity we got to see this band that meant so much to us. We went back to Holmfirth again in 2011 and since then The Wedding Present have become the catalyst for us to get together regularly for the best possible reason. Any tour announcements are followed by a flurry of excited WhatsApp messages as we work out which gigs we’re going to and start researching nearby Travelodges and pubs. 

Left to right: Simon, me, Rich, Mike @ The Wedding Present gig, Manchester Academy 14/11/15. Photo by Tom Williams.

In the last decade we have met up to see The Wedding Present in Bristol, Chester, Wolverhampton, Blackpool, Wakefield, Liverpool and multiple times in London and Manchester. And Sheffield which is where this tale began. 

Sheffield (February 2018)

Mike said he didn’t want any kind of big stag weekend. He just wanted to meet up somewhere, have a few beers and go to see The Wedding Present. Great fortune for us that there was a Saturday night gig coming up in Sheffield, a city we all have great affection for. Simon used to live there and we all have treasured (albeit hazy) memories of visiting him up there to explore the city’s pubs, parties, curry houses and chip shops. 

Shortly before the gig, I interviewed superhero drummer Charlie Layton. I told him a little of the backstory you’ve just read and that the 4 of us  were celebrating Mike’s stag weekend at the Sheffield gig. Being the lovely chap that he is, Charlie must’ve asked David to give us a shoutout. We appreciated it all the more because we all know that’s not the kind of thing David is comfortable doing. A bit too naff, fake and showbizzy. Like doing encores. One of many things that makes them the semi-legendary band they are.

Neither Charlie or David would’ve known that the song they dedicated to us was the first Wedding Present song I ever heard, the one on that tape from Melody Maker.

But the title of the song couldn’t have been more appropriate. No matter how it ends, you really should keep in touch with your friends. 

If I’m honest the rest of that song’s lyrics have lost most of their impact. The girl in Ostend is long forgotten, to quote A Million Miles “I can’t even remember the colour of her eyes.” I’m not that lovelorn teenager anymore. Nor indeed am I the overgrown lovelorn teenager that I remained for many years after that. So as good as they are, it’s not the lyrics that get me these days. That’s not what hits me hard. It’s the noisy guitars. It’s still the noisy guitars. It will always be the noisy guitars. Nobody does it better. Baby you’re the best.

More Wedding Present articles on this website:

Wedding Present live reviews on this website:

Podcast episodes where we have played The Wedding Present / Cinerama songs:

Robert Pollard’s Guide To The 60s – Tape 32: Plastic Ono Band – John Lennon / Paranoid – Black Sabbath

Here we consider the relative merits of John Lennon’s first solo album and the second album from Black Sabbath.

Suffice to say, some strong emotions were expressed in the making of this podcast.

You can find out what we made of these landmark albums by clicking on the image below.

Our chats about the previous tapes can be found where you found this one.

To avoid any potential disappointment on missing out on the next show, make sure you follow our podcast on Spotify or subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

Live review: The Only Ones / Crimewave @ Trades Club, Hebden Bridge, 3rd August 2023

I’ve written before on this website about my first job working at The HMV Shop when I was 17 and being surrounded by older, cooler, more knowledgeable people who helped widen my musical horizons. One of the most important of those was the shop manager, a wiry bloke from Blackpool called Andy, still to this day one of the best bosses I’ve ever had and a much beloved figure amongst HMV alumni. Knowing that I was into The Damned, Buzzcocks and especially The Clash, he asked me one day if I’d heard of The Only Ones. My blank look in response was all the encouragement needed for him to arrive the next morning holding a carrier bag containing his records from home for me to borrow and make tape copies of. Gawd bless the TDK AR90 blank tape, I’m sure I spent most of my HMV wages on them!

In Andy’s carrier bag were all 3 of their albums, “The Only Ones” (1978), “Even Serpents Shine” (1979) and “Baby’s Got A Gun” (1980)

On those records, a world-weary voice sounds very sorry for itself and seems resigned to being one of life’s losers.

“Why do I go through these deep emotional traumas? Why can’t I be happy like everybody else?” 

A teenage Smiths fan like me was always going to fall in love with a band that start a song like that, even if the closest the 17 year old me had ever got to “deep emotional trauma” was having a faceful of acne and being unable to get a girlfriend.

Musically, there was a lot more going on here than the “wun-doo-free-for” surge of straightforward Ramones-style songs. Punk was generally anti-guitar solo and Mick Jones had even perfected the anti-guitar solo guitar solo (e.g. “Cheat” “Remote Control” “White Riot”) Proper tricky-to-play lead guitar lines and solos were all over these Only Ones records, perhaps a clue to why they didn’t fit in at the time and why commercial success never came anywhere near them. Their third album made it to number 37 in the album charts and the previous two didn’t even make it that high. None of their singles got anywhere near the Top 40, not even “Another Girl Another Planet” which is by many light years their best-known song. But they have definitely acquired “cult band” status because over the years I’ve met lots of people who love these records just as much as Andy and I do.

Back then the possibility of seeing The Only Ones live seemed less than zero. They’d not been heard of since they split in 1982 and frontman Peter Perrett was reportedly lost to junkiedom. I don’t know if many people remember Volume magazine which ran from 1991 to 1996 and may well have been the first music magazine to include a free CD in every issue. I bought every one on release and I was very excited to hear a new song called “Daughter” by “Peter Perrett’s The One” when it appeared on “Volume Ten” in 1994. The accompanying magazine article talked of a forthcoming solo album which took a while to actually appear and was a bit of a disappointment when it did. To my ears, 1996’s “Woke Up Sticky” sounded a bit insubstantial, like a watered down pint. Not sure why because it was produced by Marc Waterman who had previously done some astoundingly good work producing early singles by two of my favourite bands of the early 90s, Five Thirty and Ash. Maybe I should dig out the CD and re-listen?

My box set of the first 10 “Volume” magazines

A quarter of a century after the initial split and prompted by the use of “Another Girl, Another Planet” in a Vodafone advert, The Only Ones reformed for a handful of gigs in 2007. On holiday in Scotland with Mrs Garbanzo, we heard about the Connect Festival going on nearby in the grounds of Inveraray Castle, easily the most spectacular festival location I’ve ever been to. We had a great time seeing Bjork, Tilly & The Wall, and Orbital, but we weren’t able to go for the whole weekend which meant we weren’t there when The Only Ones played on the Saturday! That was my big chance to see them gone. Bollocks. “Why can’t I be happy like everybody else?”

So I was delighted to hear radio legend Marc Riley mention this new reunion a few months ago and an opportunity for me to finally see the band live. This mini-tour comprised of 2 sold-out nights at Hebden Bridge before a weekend appearance at the Rebellion Festival in Blackpool. The line-up included 3 of the 4 original bandmembers, Peter Perrett (vocals, guitar) Alan Mair (bass) and John Perry (guitar). Very sadly, drummer Mike Kellie passed away in 2017.

This was my second gig at Hebden Bridge Trades Club. It’s a great venue that books loads of bands I like, but I live nearly 2 hours drive away so it’s nearly really that viable most of the time. My previous time here was a flying visit 10 and a bit years ago to see the always brilliant Chuck Prophet & The Mission Express. This time around I had time to look around a bit before the gig and to take a scenic route on the drive up here, exploring the Calder Valley. Wow, what a beautiful part of the world this is! Not only that but the town centre seems to be full of enticing community-owned craft ale pubs that I would’ve loved to have gone into had I not been driving. You can see why it’s been nicknamed Happy Valley.

I walked up to the train station to meet my mate The Lancashire Toreador who’d travelled up from Manchester. Then we got into the venue just in time for the support act Crimewave. They’re a one man outfit and that one man is Jake Wilkinson. In his militaristic khaki t-shirt and maroon beret, he looks like a Holy Bible-era Manic Street Preacher, but sounds more like the Manics a few years later when they started deliberately alienating their newly acquired mainstream fanbase by commissioning the likes of Mogwai, Cornelius, Fuck Buttons and Four Tet to create noisenik remixes of their singles.

Crimewave @ Hebden Bridge Trades Club, 3/8/23

Armed with just a guitar, a Midi pad and a laptop, Crimewave were all frantic breakbeats and blasts of Spacemen 3-style guitar accompanied by a big screen backdrop showing blurry CCTV footage of various violent incidents, like watching an episode of Crimewatch through a frosted window. The music was mostly instrumental and any lyrics were impossible to make out. But the songtitles on his Bandcamp page (Ultraviolent Crime, Metropolitan Police, Dispersal Order) certainly suggest that they fit in with the backdrop images and the bandname.

Crimewave’s performance was reminiscent of a bloke called Joe from Wigan whose performs as TV-AM. We played his single “No Explanations” on our podcast in 2014 and I’ve caught him live a couple of times, supporting Moon Duo in Liverpool and Dengue Fever in Manchester. Two full-length albums later, I’m hoping to catch him again at Manchester Psych Fest next month.

After a while, The Lancashire Toreador was finding the visuals a bit much and starting to feel like Malcolm McDowell in A Clockwork Orange having his eyelids held open by wires. He decided to listen to the rest of the gig standing with his back to the stage. I did a similar thing the second time I saw Tricky back in 90s. Having seen him support PJ Harvey and play in almost complete darkness save for a couple of dim blue lights, when I saw him again at a festival soon after I decided to sit down with my back to a massive speaker by the mixing desk. It was a waste of effort trying to watch the “show” because it was 100% about the sound, not the vision. It meant that I only needed to use one of my senses to absorb the performance but I think I actually enjoyed that gig far more than the one that I’d actually watched!

The Toreador’s verdict was that it didn’t lose anything from just listening, not watching. But I thought the visuals were powerful and added to the ominous feeling of hostility and menace in the music.

Overall it was quite an onslaught and a great choice for the support slot.

Don’t have nightmares, sleep well.

Soon after, The Only Ones walked onstage with all Perrett, Mair and Perry all wearing sunglasses indoors and getting away with it as only the supercool can. They were joined by Perrett’s son Jamie (ex-Babyshambles) on additional guitar and drummer Steve Hands, who also played on Peter Perrett’s aforementioned “Woke Up Sticky” album, and did an absolutely magnificent job filling in here.

They opened with “Peter & The Pets,” originally released on the the B-side of their debut single “Lovers Of Today.” It was clear from the very first lines that Perrett’s tired drawl sounded just the same as it did on that record and still hit me with the same emotional punch. Standing to his left, John Perry knocked out the song’s nimble lead guitar lines perfectly, gazing out into the crowd and seemingly not even needing to pay any attention to what he was playing.

Other early highlights of the gig included “Why Don’t You Kill Yourself?” a song I remember being met with incredulous looks from my kids when I’d played it in the car a while ago. They couldn’t believe that anyone had been allowed to get away with singing that! Different times, children, different times. What a great song it is though. It’s always been one of my favourites and it was played brilliantly here by the whole band but especially Alan Mair who filled in the spaces with some fantastic Entwistle-style runs.

That song is from the third and final album “Baby’s Got A Gun” and should the incredibly unlikely scenario ever occur whereby somehow a baby got a gun and held it to my head demanding that I tell them my favourite Only Ones album, I’d probably say that the second album “Even Serpents Shine” just shades it ahead of that one.  

The 2 opening songs from that album were played soon after and both were amazing.

“Flaming Torch” has our hero resigned to failure again singing “I think our life together has been cursed, I don’t know which one of us is worse” and the irresistibly singalong chorus “I’m always in the wrong place at the wrong time.” More dazzling guitar playing from John Perry on “From Here To Eternity” and more lyrics of doomed romance. Perrett should be lifting up his top to reveal a “Why always me?” slogan like a post-punk Mario Balotelli.

Along the way, Perrett gave a shoutout to the much-missed drummer Mike Kellie, greeted with a big cheer from the crowd. In an interview with John Robb at Rebellion a couple of days later, Perrett said that Kellie was such a key part of the band, he now felt quite uncomfortable using the bandname without him.

The Only Ones @ Hebden Bridge Trades Club, 3/8/23

Perrett introduced “Trouble In The World” with the words “we haven’t done this one in a long time” before correcting himself and saying “we haven’t done anything in a long time!”

As the end of the main set approached, they played a cover of The Kinks song “I’m Not Like Everybody Else,” performed with a lot more vim and passion than the version on “Woke Up Sticky” and all the better for it.

Inevitably “Another Girl Another Planet” was the loudest audience singalong of the night. I was transfixed watching John Perry play that opening lead guitar line and even more so when he played the guitar solo in the middle. I know how hard it is to play that solo because I’ve been trying to master it for 30 something years (still a work in progress!) John Perry makes it look absolutely effortless, that’s how fucking good he is! I particularly loved the moment when he nonchalantly pushed his sunglasses up his nose with his right hand while his left hand just carried on bending the note.

Name me a cooler guitarist. I’ll wait.

See for yourself 2 minutes into this video.

The little sunglasses flourish prompted a memory of seeing The Stranglers in Liverpool many years ago when the late, great Dave Greenfield downed a pint during the trickiest part of the “No More Heroes” keyboard solo.  

Even better was to follow with “The Beast,” a standout song from the debut album and a song that both The Lancashire Toreador and I had mentioned as being a favourite on our pre-gig walk from the train station. There’s also a brilliant version on their Peel Sessions compilation album.

Both the original and the Peel version clock in at just under 6 minutes, making them the longest song the band ever recorded. But the 2023 live version is extended even further and was breathtakingly great, possibly my favourite song of the whole gig.

As they came back out for the encore, Perrett said they were going to try something else they’d never done before, a medley. The song had the chorus and chords from Neil Young’s “Helpless” but with different words in the verses. I’ve since learned that it is called “Don’t Feel Too Good” and it was released on a round-up of non-album songs called “Remains,” as was “Prisoners” which was also played in the encore.

After a fairly standard bar-band run-through of “Baby Let Me Follow You Down,” Perrett thanked the crowd for allowing him to indulge his fantasy of being Bob Dylan in 1966. A quick-witted crowdmember responded with a “Judas” shout.

Then the final song of the encore and another absolute golden moment when they played “Someone Who Cares,” another of my favourite songs from “Even Serpents Shine”

Another song that features plenty of that nihilistic romanticism I’ve already mentioned: “I’m scared of losing the most precious thing I own, wake up one day to find the bird has flown.”

But there’s also another thread that runs through lots of Only Ones lyrics. It’s the faint chance of redemption, the possibility of some beams of light at the end of the tunnel. I can take the despair, it’s the hope I can’t stand. “I hope you find someone who cares.”

Regular readers of my gig reviews (hello to you both) will know that I can occasionally get nitpicky about setlists, so here comes that bit.

Only 12 of the 19 songs (63%) they played were what I would describe as well-established Only Ones songs from their golden era. As well as the B-sides of their first 2 singles (“Peter & The Pets”, “As My Wife Says”) they  played 3 songs each from “The Only Ones” and “Baby’s Got A Gun” and 4 from “Even Serpents Shine.”

I would’ve loved to hear the A-side of that debut single “Lovers Of Today” as well as later singles “You’ve Got To Pay” and especially “Out There In The Night,” another song about lost love that I can really imagine going down a storm here.

Lots of other favourites from the albums were absent too… The Lancashire Toreador’s favourite “No Solution”…  “The Whole Of The Law”… “Language Problem” … “No Peach For The Wicked” … “Miles From Nowhere” … “In Betweens” (although let’s be fair, those last 2 were played at the following night’s gig.)

Instead we got 2 as yet unreleased songs “Black Operations” and “Louder Than Words” and 3 songs from the “Remains” round-up album. No doubt there were a few hardcore Only Ones fans at the gig who were as delighted to hear some relative obscurities being played as I am when the same thing happens at a Wedding Present gig.

But The Wedding Present are pretty much constantly on tour and nearly all of their audience are, like me, repeat customers. So much so in fact, that they end every gig by jokingly asking if there’s anyone there who’s never seen them before.

In contrast, The Only Ones have played about a dozen UK gigs in the last 30 years! So in the circumstances, I’d be happy to sacrifice hearing those little-known songs and the 2 covers and have them replaced with some of the more familiar favourites mentioned above instead. I suspect most of the other audience members might have felt the same judging by the slightly underwhelmed reaction to most of the encore songs.

OK, griping over. Apologies for sounding like an entitled little princess.

Here are some photos from from the gig that are far better than the ones I took.

Robert Pollard’s Guide To The 60s – Bonus episode: Half time

Having discussed 31 of the 62 tapes in Robert Pollard’s collection, we are now exactly halfway through our podcast series.

Before we head into the second half, let’s all take a little breather, grab a slice of orange and share some statistics.

Click below to take a listen.

Here’s the playlist Chorizo has compiled, featuring his favourite songs that he’s heard for the first time through making this podcast.

https://open.spotify.com/embed/playlist/1x5iDgx6T9ftkR4P40nvgm?utm_source=generator&theme=0

Our chats about the previous tapes can be found where you found this one.

To avoid any potential disappointment on missing out on the next show, make sure you follow our podcast on Spotify or subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

Robert Pollard’s Guide To The 60s – Tape 31: Waiting For The Sun / The Soft Parade – The Doors

On this podcast the wizards take a look at a couple of albums from that band who seem to always be on the ticket, but never bother to turn up. The Doors!

You can find out what we made of The Door’s third and fourth albums by clicking on the image below.

Our chats about the previous tapes can be found where you found this one.

To avoid any potential disappointment on missing out on the next show, make sure you follow our podcast on Spotify or subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

Robert Pollard’s Guide To The 60s – Tape 30: Selected Tracks by The Attack / Seven Lonely Street – Andromeda

Another tape where Uncle Bob failed to name an album, so we have handpicked 10 tracks from The Attack to review along with a compilation of unreleased recorcordings from Andromeda, featuring at least one of the same musicians.

You can find out what we made of this little lot by clicking on the image below.

Our chats about the previous tapes can be found where you found this one.

To avoid any potential disappointment on missing out on the next show, make sure you follow our podcast on Spotify or subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

Robert Pollard’s Guide To The 60s – Tape 29: Deja Vu – Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young / After The Goldrush – Neil Young

If you’re a fan of band in-fighting, and, frankly, who isn’t? – this podcast will be right up your 4-Way Street. The undoubted talents of David Crosby, Stephen Stills, Graham Nash and Neil Young combined with their undoubted egos make for quite the tale as we consider the merits of the CSN&Y album, Deja Vu and the Neil Young solo album that followed, After The Goldrush.

Just look at those happy faces!

You can find out what we made of both albums by clicking on the image below.

Kicker mentioned putting together a playlist of Neil Young Piano songs, but Mr Young doesn’t make it very easy to share his songs online (rightly, I guess), so here’s a list for you to put the playlist together yourselves. Please let us know what we need to add!

Philadelphia

After The Goldrush

Borrowed Tune

Love In Mind

My Heart

It’s A Dream

A Man Needs A Maid

Stringman

Soldier

Birds

Journey Through The Past

Speakin’ Out

Our chats about the previous tapes can be found where you found this one.

To avoid any potential disappointment on missing out on the next show, make sure you follow our podcast on Spotify or subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

Spare Snare – The Brutal (Album review with Jan Burnett)

Despite Kicker getting the name of the album wrong and mishearing some of the lyrics, Jan Burnett still agrees to talk him through the making of the brilliant new Spare Snare album, The Brutal, ahead of its release in May.

Listen to their engaging and informative (at least from one of the parties) chat by clicking on the album artwork below.

The new album is available for pre-order now on vinyl, CD and download:

You can also see the band live during May and June, and we very much recommend that you do.

Our earlier chat with Jan can be found here: Q&A with Jan Burnett

You can find the Spare Snare back catalogue on Bandcamp.

You should also join the Spare Snare Subscription service to make sure you don’t miss out on any of those rare releases.

Robert Pollard’s Guide To The 60s – Tape 28: Selected tracks from Wimple Winch and Keith West

This is the first of Robert Pollard’s tapes that did not specify any particular albums, rather just the two artists: Wimple Winch and Keith West.

All of the tracks Kicker and Chorizo listened to were taken from the two compilation albums pictured below.

You can find out what we made of them by clicking on the image below.

The highly recommended compilation album that Kicker talks about is this one:

Chorizo also found an interesting interview with Keith West that you can find by clicking on the picture below.

Our chats about the previous tapes can be found where you found this one.

To avoid any potential disappointment on missing out on the next show, make sure you follow our podcast on Spotify or subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

Q & A with Simon Love + 2 exclusive acoustic songs

Here’s our interview with Simon Love, a long-term favourite of ours here at TTW.

Don’t miss this one because the recording also includes a couple of exclusive “in session” performances. Simon plays a couple of acoustic songs, one old favourite and the premiere of a brand new song.

Download here

Related posts